Skip to contentNational Women's Law Center

Third Circuit Court of Appeals Says Conestoga Wood Specialties Must Comply with Contraceptive Coverage Benefit

Conestoga Wood Specialties is one of the almost 30 plus companies challenging the contraceptive coverage benefit. Conestoga has been arguing that, as a secular, for-profit corporation, it can exercise religious beliefs and that it should be allowed to impose those religious beliefs and the beliefs of its owners on its employees. Today, the 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals said, quite simply, “no way!”  

The court’s decision makes three important points: (1) Conestoga, as a for-profit, secular corporation, cannot exercise religious beliefs; (2) the Hahns, Conestoga’s owners, cannot impose their religious beliefs on their employees through their company; and (3) the decision does not disrespect the Hahns’ religious objections to contraception.

First, the court said upfront that Conestoga, as a “for-profit, secular corporation[] cannot engage in religious exercise.” “In fact,” the court continued, “we are not aware of any case preceding the commencement of litigation about the [contraceptive coverage benefit], in which a for-profit, secular corporation was itself found to have free exercise rights.” That’s because there is none. For-profit, secular corporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief.

Second, the court acknowledged that while the company’s owners, the Hahns, may have religious beliefs, they cannot impose those beliefs on their workers through their company. The court recognized, “Since Conestoga is distinct from the Hahns, the [contraceptive coverage benefit] does not actually require the Hahns to do anything. All responsibility for complying with the [contraceptive coverage benefit] falls on Conestoga.” And, again: back to (1): complying with the contraceptive coverage benefit does not interfere with Conestoga’s religious exercise because Conestoga itself cannot have religious beliefs.

Finally, the court noted: “[O]ur decision here is in no way intended to marginalize the Hahns’ commitment to [their] faith . . . . We simply conclude that the law has long recognized the distinction between the owners of a corporation and the corporation itself.” The acknowledgement by the court here is true—the court’s decision says nothing about the Hahns’ ability to profess their religious beliefs as individuals. It simply reaffirms the idea that the Hahns cannot impose their religious beliefs on their workers. As the court points out, “[a] holding to the contrary—that a for-profit corporation can engage in religious exercise—would eviscerate the fundamental principle that a corporation is a legally distinct entity from its owners.”

So, Conestoga cannot get out of complying with the contraceptive coverage benefit and must provide its workers with health insurance that includes coverage for birth control. Great news to hear on a Friday—looking forward to more decisions like this one!

Comments

will find a lot of approaches

will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. Great work. ovarian cyst miracle

As the court points out, “[a]

As the court points out, “[a] holding to the contrary—that a for-profit corporation can engage in religious exercise—would eviscerate the fundamental principle that a corporation is a legally distinct entity from its owners.”rel garasi dan pintu besi

As the court points out, “[a]

As the court points out, “[a] holding to the contrary—that a for-profit corporation can engage in religious exercise—would eviscerate the fundamental principle that a corporation is a legally distinct entity from its owners.”rel garasi dan pintu besi

web content to be edited from

web content to be edited from anywhere, directly in the browser. Learn how to use this feature from Muse master... read more

knowledge about this issue,

knowledge about this issue, and so much passion. You also know how to make people rally behind i.. http://cambogiagarcinia.ch

Keep up the good work

Keep up the good work andplease tell me when can you publish more articles or where can I read more on the subject.. click here

As the court points out, “[a]

As the court points out, “[a] holding to the contrary—that a for-profit corporation can engage in religious exercise—would eviscerate the fundamental principle that a corporation is a legally distinct entity from its owners.”Move to mexico

very fortunate to have found

very fortunate to have found good information from this article, it is very useful for me, for sure I will come back here to see the next article. online schools for pharmacy technician

After a quick demonstration,

After a quick demonstration, Dwyer decided it was the solution his new project had been looking for. painters jacksonville fl

Education, Labor and Pensions

Education, Labor and Pensions committee, asserted in an Education Week blog last month, ESEA was meant to help lift children out of poverty by making high-quality education accessible to all.Jody Kriss

Find Charity Lawyers for all

Find Charity Lawyers for all your legal issues, our lawyers are best rated professionals in law and legal issues. Explore more lawyers, attornies, consultants and barristers to solve your legal problems.
Charity Lawyers

it can exercise religious

it can exercise religious beliefs and that it should be allowed to impose those religious beliefs and the beliefs of its owners on its employees. Today, the 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals said, quite simply, “no way!” Felix Sater

Since then there have been a

Since then there have been a number of innovations, such as lining the interior of faucets with PEX, and the metallurgy of low-lead brass has made big advances.Felix Sater

Very likely I’m going to

Very likely I’m going to bookmark your blog . You absolutely have wonderful stories... http://aeratorrental.org/

Kitchen Alternatives is a

Kitchen Alternatives is a full service kitchen and bathroom remodeling company that will help you create the perfect kitchen or bathroom for you home. best cookware sets

orporations are not churches

orporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belie.. http://residentialgenerators.org/

contraceptive coverage

contraceptive coverage benefit and must provide its workers with health insurance that includes coverage for birth control. Great news to hear on a Friday—looking forward to more decisions like this one!mobil termahal di dunia

I read your blog very

I read your blog very interesting topic you shared with us love it and make it more perfection in your post.. home theater kingwood tx

d definitely liked this blog

d definitely liked this blog site. Very likely I’m going to bookmark your blog . You absolutely have wonderful stories.... car shipping quotes

an engage in religious

an engage in religious exercise—would eviscerate the fundamental pr.. auto transport

ovarian cyst miracle carol foster reviews

I simply want to tell you that I am new to weblog and definitely liked this blog site. Very likely I’m going to bookmark your blog . You absolutely have wonderful stories. Cheers for sharing with us your blog.ovarian cyst miracle carol foster reviews

resh them and make any

resh them and make any necessary maintenance, careful to fix up any problem areas that might put buyers off. video advertising

coconut and once savings are

coconut and once savings are sufficient build a coconut harvesting tool that will yield 20 coconuts a day while using those coconuts . best fiverr gigs for backlinks

secular corporations are not

secular corporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief... blog commenting seo service

complying with the

complying with the contraceptive coverage benefit does not interfere with Conestoga’s religious exercise because Conestoga itself cannot have religious beliefs.reconditioned gearboxes

THank you

For-profit, secular corporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief
bruidsfotografie

best ways to get rid of heartburn fast

Thanks for sharing the information. I am so helped by this.Please share more on this. I am eagerly waiting to have more.best ways to get rid of heartburn fast

that a for-profit corporation

that a for-profit corporation can engage in religious exercise—would eviscerate the fundamental principle. Webdesign Nürnberg

corporations are not churches

corporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief.l.. Paper recycling impact calculator

nd cheers to you for all the

nd cheers to you for all the environmental actions you're doing as well! .. RugoLand

Plains. Weekly temperatures

Plains. Weekly temperatures averaged more than 10° F above normal across parts of the Intermountain ....cFree PDF Ebooks

That’s because there is none.

That’s because there is none. For-profit, secular corporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief.fifa 15 coins

I am so helped by this.Please

I am so helped by this.Please share more on this. I am eagerly waiting to have more.. akrilik

As the court points out, “[a]

As the court points out, “[a] holding to the contrary—that a for-profit corporation can engage in religious exercise—would eviscerate the fundamental principle that a corporation is a legally distinct entity from its owners.”پارتیشن

That’s because there is none.

That’s because there is none. For-profit, secular corporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief.loft conversions ealing

This is really a nice and

This is really a nice and informative, containing all information and also has a great impact on the new technology. Thanks for sharing it, debt consolidation loans

Spring may not yet be upon

Spring may not yet be upon us, but these California natives have us dreaming of the surf, the sand, and our next summer fling. As of today, the St. Croix EP is officially out on the market and ready for some mass consumption.red chili

I simply want to tell you

I simply want to tell you that I am new to weblog and definitely liked this blog site. Very likely I’m going to bookmark your blog . You absolutely have wonderful stories. Cheers for sharing with us your blog.Do follow blog comments here

Very strong boot for my work!

Very strong boot for my work! Thanks for sharing! web site tasarımı

it can exercise religious

it can exercise religious beliefs and that it should be allowed to impose those religious beliefs and the beliefs of its owners on its employees. Today, the 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals said, quite simply, “no way!” Trucos de beleza

For-profit, secular

For-profit, secular corporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief.Symphony Suites

really what I wanted to see

really what I wanted to see hope in future you will continue for sharing such a excellent post... texas drug rehab

complying with the

complying with the contraceptive coverage benefit does not interfere with Conestoga’s religious exercise because Conestoga itself cannot have religious beliefs.. چت

coverage benefit does not

coverage benefit does not interfere with Conestoga’s religious exercise because Conestoga itself cannot have religious beliefs.. Endometriosis Symptoms

Starting with a simple goal

Starting with a simple goal of walking for 20 minutes is a simple goal. That's where I started from last year in May, and by October I was running the Army 10 miler. Of course, this year I'm starting from the same spot.چت

Admiring the time and effort

Admiring the time and effort you put into your blog and detailed information you offer.Thanks. garcinia cambogia extract dr oz

garbage. If they find other

garbage. If they find other improperly sorted waste, they send you a municipal citation and collect a portion of the fine... unblock websites

would eviscerate the

would eviscerate the fundamental principle that a corporation is a legally distinct entity from its owners.”... good backlink service

careful to fix up any problem

careful to fix up any problem areas that might put buyers off..... cincher corset

Thanks for sharing the

Thanks for sharing the information. I am so helped by this.Please share more on this. I am eagerly waiting to have moreUnqie domains pr7

Post new comment