Skip to contentNational Women's Law Center

Third Circuit Court of Appeals Says Conestoga Wood Specialties Must Comply with Contraceptive Coverage Benefit

Conestoga Wood Specialties is one of the almost 30 plus companies challenging the contraceptive coverage benefit. Conestoga has been arguing that, as a secular, for-profit corporation, it can exercise religious beliefs and that it should be allowed to impose those religious beliefs and the beliefs of its owners on its employees. Today, the 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals said, quite simply, “no way!”  

The court’s decision makes three important points: (1) Conestoga, as a for-profit, secular corporation, cannot exercise religious beliefs; (2) the Hahns, Conestoga’s owners, cannot impose their religious beliefs on their employees through their company; and (3) the decision does not disrespect the Hahns’ religious objections to contraception.

First, the court said upfront that Conestoga, as a “for-profit, secular corporation[] cannot engage in religious exercise.” “In fact,” the court continued, “we are not aware of any case preceding the commencement of litigation about the [contraceptive coverage benefit], in which a for-profit, secular corporation was itself found to have free exercise rights.” That’s because there is none. For-profit, secular corporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief.

Second, the court acknowledged that while the company’s owners, the Hahns, may have religious beliefs, they cannot impose those beliefs on their workers through their company. The court recognized, “Since Conestoga is distinct from the Hahns, the [contraceptive coverage benefit] does not actually require the Hahns to do anything. All responsibility for complying with the [contraceptive coverage benefit] falls on Conestoga.” And, again: back to (1): complying with the contraceptive coverage benefit does not interfere with Conestoga’s religious exercise because Conestoga itself cannot have religious beliefs.

Finally, the court noted: “[O]ur decision here is in no way intended to marginalize the Hahns’ commitment to [their] faith . . . . We simply conclude that the law has long recognized the distinction between the owners of a corporation and the corporation itself.” The acknowledgement by the court here is true—the court’s decision says nothing about the Hahns’ ability to profess their religious beliefs as individuals. It simply reaffirms the idea that the Hahns cannot impose their religious beliefs on their workers. As the court points out, “[a] holding to the contrary—that a for-profit corporation can engage in religious exercise—would eviscerate the fundamental principle that a corporation is a legally distinct entity from its owners.”

So, Conestoga cannot get out of complying with the contraceptive coverage benefit and must provide its workers with health insurance that includes coverage for birth control. Great news to hear on a Friday—looking forward to more decisions like this one!

Comments

Lots of people prefer buying

Lots of people prefer buying a Windows VPS rather than a Shared Hosting or a Dedicated Server Hosting.. http://shampooforcurlyhair.wordpress.com/

. For-profit, secular

. For-profit, secular corporations are not churches or religious entities.. good backlink service

That’s because there is none.

That’s because there is none. For-profit, secular corporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief...boostmytest.com

All responsibility for

All responsibility for complying with the [contraceptive coverage benefit] falls on Conestoga. Download PDF Ebooks

Hosting has gained a lot of

Hosting has gained a lot of popularity. Lots of people prefer buying a Windows VPS rather than a Shared Hosting or a Dedicated Server Hosting... barbie brazilian hair

Id recommend something else.

Id recommend something else. It had recessed air pillows over the eyes, so it didn't press down on your eyeballs. Free PDF Ebooks

Overall, Id recommend

Overall, Id recommend something else. It had recessed air pillows over the eyes, so it didn't press down on your eyeballs.. debt relief

If you imagine it as a farce;

If you imagine it as a farce; a parody; a joke...then you can enjoy it for its sheer ridiculousness. best site to buy facebook likes

That’s because there is none.

That’s because there is none. For-profit, secular corporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief pc cleaner

Id recommend something else.

Id recommend something else. It had recessed air pillows over the eyes, so it didn't press down on your eyeballs. star wars commander cheat

Berikut di bawah ini adalah

Berikut di bawah ini adalah daftar situs iklan baris gratis yang dapat di submit iklan otomatis menggunakan software autosubmit, http://www.airysoftware.com/system-optimizer.htm

That’s because there is none.

That’s because there is none. For-profit, secular corporations are not churches or religious entities.. our website

That’s because there is none.

That’s because there is none. For-profit, secular corporations are not churches or religious entities.. vista verde q2

orporations are not churches

orporations are not churches or religious entities, Berikut di bawah ini adalah daftar situs iklan baris gratis yang dapat di submit iklan otomatis menggunakan software autosubmit,

. If you imagine it as a

. If you imagine it as a farce; a parody; a joke...then you can enjoy it for its sheer ridiculousness. I have had this Breville BOV800XL Oven for a year. Free PDF Ebooks

vps windows

These days windows vps Hosting has gained a lot of popularity. Lots of people prefer buying a Windows VPS rather than a Shared Hosting or a Dedicated Server Hosting as it offers large number of benefits to its users.

also listen to her speech in

also listen to her speech in the public and it was really an honor to see and able to be a part of her speech and event regarding Certified nursing assistant - Resource

are not churches or religious

are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief. CNA Training and schools

orporations are not churches

orporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief. Find more information

re not churches or religious

re not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief. http://iphone5unlockexperts.com

Diabetes Type 2

Overall, Id recommend something else. It had recessed air pillows over the eyes, so it didn't press down on your eyeballs. If you imagine it as a farce; a parody; a joke...then you can enjoy it for its sheer ridiculousness. I have had this Breville BOV800XL Oven for a year. Diabetes Type 2
So when I thought to buy a power adapter, I turned to Amazon. I changed my old Brother HL2140 with this new toner cartridge. This is great tape! I have to wear a knee brace most of the time, and it slips down. I know Canon also makes a battery that 'bolts-on' to the back of this printer. I've just received the camera and have taken a few test shots. Pizza is good with a good pan. www.sandiegowaltz.org. Party Food Ideas For Diabetics Click here

that a for-profit corporation

that a for-profit corporation can engage in religious exercise—would eviscerate the fundamental principle that a corporation is a legally distinct entity from its owners.”Clik Health

are not churches or religious

are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief. clip hair extensions

As the court points out, “[a]

As the court points out, “[a] holding to the contrary—that a for-profit corporation can engage in religious exercise—would eviscerate the fundamental principle that a corporation is a legally distinct entity from its owners.” jeffrey killino

are not churches or religious

are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief. Nissan Silvia spare parts

not individuals that may

not individuals that may express religious belief....List on MLS

BlackMen

The court recognized, “Since Conestoga is distinct from the Hahns, the [contraceptive coverage benefit] does not actually require the Hahns to do anything. All responsibility for complying with the [contraceptive coverage benefit] falls on Conestoga.” And, again: back to (1): complying with the contraceptive coverage benefit does not interfere with Conestoga’s religious exercise because Conestoga itself cannot have religious beliefs. Isis Consulting agency

contraceptive coverage

contraceptive coverage benefit does not interfere with Conestoga’s religious exercise because Conestoga itself cannot have religious beliefs...reviews online

BlackMen

That’s because there is none. For-profit, secular corporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief. Buy Website Traffic

which a for-profit, secular

which a for-profit, secular corporation was itself found to have free exercise rights.” That’s because there is none. For-profit, secular corporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief Alcoa Inc.

corporation was itself found

corporation was itself found to have free exercise rights.” That’s because there is none. For-profit, secular.....boostmytest.com

itself found to have free

itself found to have free exercise rights.” That’s because there is none. For-profit, secular corporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious beliefunderground racing

BlackMen

It simply reaffirms the idea that the Hahns cannot impose their religious beliefs on their workers. As the court points out, “[a] holding to the contrary—that a for-profit corporation can engage in religious exercise—would eviscerate the fundamental principle that a corporation is a legally distinct entity from its owners.” rug cleaners NYC

which a for-profit, secular

which a for-profit, secular corporation was itself found to have free exercise rights.” That’s because there is none. For-profit, secular corporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief. Retail POS System

As the court points out, “[a]

As the court points out, “[a] holding to the contrary—that a for-profit corporation can engage in religious exercise—would eviscerate the fundamental principle that a corporation is a legally distinct entity from its owners.” website

it can exercise religious

it can exercise religious beliefs and that it should be allowed to impose those religious beliefs and the beliefs of its owners on its employees. Today, the 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals said, quite simply, “no way!” parapharmacie en ligne

ts like men and women aren’t

ts like men and women aren’t fascinated until it’s one thing to accomplish with Girl gaga! Your own stuffs outstanding. All the time handle it up! Baltimore Lawyers

BlackMen

Fortunately, the Law has been able to survive these onslaughts against our right to clean water. However, as we approach the 40th anniversary of the Clean Water Act in October, polluters and friends of polluters are increasing the number and intensity of their attacks. Visit this link

william

Its like men and women aren’t fascinated until it’s one thing to accomplish with Girl gaga! Your own stuffs outstanding. All the time handle it up! http://aokmedia.co

BlackMen

The court’s decision makes three important points: (1) Conestoga, as a for-profit, secular corporation, cannot exercise religious beliefs; (2) the Hahns, Conestoga’s owners, cannot impose their religious beliefs on their employees through their company; and (3) the decision does not disrespect the Hahns’ religious objections to contraception. soundcloud downloader

what their present profits

what their present profits are on the area that they are considering transforming.....rank update your site here

So, Conestoga cannot get out

So, Conestoga cannot get out of complying with the contraceptive coverage benefit and must provide its workers with health insurance that includes coverage for birth control. Great news to hear on a Friday—looking forward to more decisions like this one! legal steroids

william

You, my friend, ROCK! I found just the info I already searched everywhere and just could not come across. What a perfect website Low Rise Forming Association

For-profit, secular

For-profit, secular corporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief is bubblegum casting legitimate

am impressed by the details

am impressed by the details that you have on this site. It reveals how nicely you perceive this subject. Bookmarked this website page, will come back for extra articles. You, my friend, ROCK! I found just the info I already searched everywhere and just could not come across. What a perfect website Booking Lesvos Tips

william

If possible, as you become expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more details ? It is highly helpful for me. Big thumb up for this blog post ! augmenter ses votes google

would you mind updating your

would you mind updating your blog with more details ? It is highly helpful for me. Big thumb up for this blog post ...View Our Privacy Policy

For-profit, secular

For-profit, secular corporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief.dofollow website backlink service

As the court points out, “[a]

As the court points out, “[a] holding to the contrary—that a for-profit corporation can engage in religious exercise—would eviscerate the fundamental principle that a corporation is a legally distinct entity from its owners.” www.thewhiteboardstore.co.uk

For-profit, secular

For-profit, secular corporations are not churches or religious entities, and are certainly not individuals that may express religious belief.. facebook hacking software

Post new comment